Test Report

Mascara test

The result of our mascara test is not black and white, but a colourful mix. Ten mascaras landed in the green zone, three products in the yellow midfield. However, there are also three "unsatisfactory" products at the deep red end of the table, all from L'Oréal.

Logo of tester Öko-Test
TesterÖko-Test
Edition03/2024

16 Products in test

1100/100

No image

Alverde Nothing but Volume Mascara 010 Black (12ml)
Unfortunately this product is currently not available in our assortment.
1100/100
Benecos Maximum Volume (Deep Black)
Mascara

Benecos Maximum Volume

Deep Black

1100/100
Dr. Hauschka Volume (No. 01 - Black)
Mascara

Dr. Hauschka Volume

No. 01 - Black

1100/100

No image

Sante Volume Sensation Mascara Nr. 01 - Black
Unfortunately this product is currently not available in our assortment.
1100/100

No image

Alterra Black Intense Volume Mascara 01 Black (13ml)
Unfortunately this product is currently not available in our assortment.
1100/100

No image

Lavera Volume Mascara, 01 Black
Unfortunately this product is currently not available in our assortment.
1100/100

No image

Terra Naturi Extreme Volume Mascara 01 Black
Unfortunately this product is currently not available in our assortment.
882/100
Catrice Glam&Doll Volume Mascara 010 (010 black)
Mascara
EUR8,18 EUR818,–/1l

Catrice Glam&Doll Volume Mascara 010

010 black

882/100

No image

Rival de Loop Ultimate Volume Fake Lashes Mascara waterproof (10 ml)
Unfortunately this product is currently not available in our assortment.
882/100

No image

Trend it up Extreme Volume Mascara Lash Heaven, 010
Unfortunately this product is currently not available in our assortment.
1150/100
essence Lash PRINCESS sculpted volume mascara (Black)
Mascara
EUR7,25 EUR604,17/1l

essence Lash PRINCESS sculpted volume mascara

Black

1150/100
Manhattan Volcano Mascara No 1010N (1010N)
Mascara

Manhattan Volcano Mascara No 1010N

1010N

1150/100

No image

Max Factor X 2000 Calorie Pro Stylist, Volume Lift & Hold, Black
Unfortunately this product is currently not available in our assortment.
148/100
Maybelline New York Colossal Volum Express Mascara (Black)
Mascara
EUR12,82 EUR1198,13/1l

Maybelline New York Colossal Volum Express Mascara

Black

148/100
NYX Professional Make-Up Worth The Hype (1 Black)
Mascara

NYX Professional Make-Up Worth The Hype

1 Black

148/100

No image

L'Oréal Voluminous Mascara (8 ml) Extra Black
Unfortunately this product is currently not available in our assortment.